Quotes for the same scope can differ by a factor of three — and so can quality. Some providers run a scanner and call it a pen test. These ten questions help you tell the difference.
1. Who will actually do the testing?
Ask for the named tester’s experience and certifications, not the company’s headline credentials.
2. How much of the testing is manual?
Manual verification, business logic testing and chaining findings together are where the value lies.
3. Can I see a sample report?
Look for an executive summary, evidence for each finding, realistic ratings, specific remediation and attack narratives.
4. How do you rate risk?
CVSS alone isn’t enough. Risk should be explained in the context of your business.
5. Will you test authenticated?
The scope should include test accounts for every user role.
6. What does the price include?
Check it’s a fixed price, and what it covers: testing days, reporting time, a debrief call and a retest.
7. Is a retest included?
A retest confirms fixes work and gives you clean evidence for auditors and clients.
8. How do you handle critical findings during the test?
Urgent issues should be reported as soon as they’re found — not weeks later in the final report.
9. How do you protect our data?
Ask about secure report delivery, retention, encrypted storage and Cyber Essentials or equivalent.
10. Do you understand our sector?
Particularly relevant for financial services, payments and other regulated firms.
A note on accreditation
CREST membership is often requested and sometimes required by procurement frameworks. It’s a useful baseline — but not a substitute for asking who will test and what you’ll actually receive.
Frequently asked questions
What should I look for in a penetration testing company?
Named, experienced testers; mostly manual testing; a sample report; risk ratings in business context; authenticated testing; a fixed price; a retest; prompt reporting of critical findings; secure data handling; and an understanding of your sector.